Skip to content

Facebook
Instagram
X (Twitter)

Welcome to BestAuthentics.com

Trusted Authentic Autographed Memorabilia

20,000 unique items for sale!

Country/region

Canada CAD $
United States USD $

Baseball
Basketball
Football
Hockey
Soccer
Boxing
Golf
Racing & More
Wrestling
Olympics
Entertainment
Political & More
Other
Services

Country/region

Canada CAD $
United States USD $

X (Twitter)
Facebook
Instagram

Search

Baseball
Basketball
Football
Hockey
Soccer
Boxing
Golf
Racing & More
Wrestling
Olympics
Entertainment
Political & More
Other
Services

Search

Item added to your cart

View cart

Collection: MLB Cleveland Indians Memorabilia

Sort by:

265 products

Filter:

Type (0)

Type

Signed (228 products)
Unsigned (7 products)

Products (0)

Products

Balls (129 products)
Bats (1 product)
Index Cards (14 products)
Magazines (3 products)
Photos (89 products)
Postcards (8 products)
Programs (3 products)
Publications (3 products)
Ticket Stubs (1 product)
Trading Cards (4 products)
Yearbooks (1 product)
Misc (2 products)

Condition (0)

Condition

New (220 products)
Very Good (9 products)
Good (2 products)
Used (3 products)
Brand New (1 product)

Price

The highest price is $339.00

$

From

To

Availability (0)

Availability

In stock (225 products)
Out of stock (40 products)

Teams (0)

Teams

MLB Cleveland Indians (131 products)

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

265 products

Type

Signed (228 products)
Unsigned (7 products)

Clear

Products

Balls (129 products)
Bats (1 products)
Index Cards (14 products)
Magazines (3 products)
Photos (89 products)
Postcards (8 products)
Programs (3 products)
Publications (3 products)
Ticket Stubs (1 products)
Trading Cards (4 products)
Yearbooks (1 products)
Misc (2 products)

Clear

Condition

New (220 products)
Very Good (9 products)
Good (2 products)
Used (3 products)
Brand New (1 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $339.00

$

From

$

To

Clear

Availability

In stock (225 products)
Out of stock (40 products)

Clear

Teams

MLB Cleveland Indians (131 products)

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

265 products

Jose Mesa Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA

Jose Mesa Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA

Regular price $58.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $58.00
Unit price per
Lou Boudreau HOF Autographed 1981 Perez-Steele Postcard Indians PSA/DNA

Lou Boudreau HOF Autographed 1981 Perez-Steele Postcard Indians PSA/DNA

Regular price $57.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $57.00
Unit price per
Rafael Perez Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Hologram 179991

Rafael Perez Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Hologram 179991

Regular price $49.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $49.00
Unit price per
Jhonny Peralta Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Holo 179987

Jhonny Peralta Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Holo 179987

Regular price $49.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $49.00
Unit price per
Omar Vizquel Signed/Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA 188475

Sold out

Omar Vizquel Signed/Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA 188475

Regular price $49.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $49.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Lot of 17 Cleveland Indians Auto/Signed 3.5x5.5 Team Photos incl.Fischlin 150665

Lot of 17 Cleveland Indians Auto/Signed 3.5x5.5 Team Photos incl.Fischlin 150665

Regular price $49.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $49.00
Unit price per
Bill Glynn Indians Signed OML Baseball JSA 138220

Sold out

Bill Glynn Indians Signed OML Baseball JSA 138220

Regular price $49.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $49.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Bob Feller HOF Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA 180821

Bob Feller HOF Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA 180821

Regular price $47.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $47.00
Unit price per
1997 World Series Game 3 Full Ticket Florida Marlins vs. Cleveland 180957

1997 World Series Game 3 Full Ticket Florida Marlins vs. Cleveland 180957

Regular price $45.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $45.00
Unit price per
Bob Lemon HOF Signed/Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians PSA/DNA 191691

Bob Lemon HOF Signed/Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians PSA/DNA 191691

Regular price $44.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $44.00
Unit price per
Victor Martinez Autographed Rawlings OML Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA 183202

Sold out

Victor Martinez Autographed Rawlings OML Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA 183202

Regular price $44.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $44.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Cleveland Indians "Play Ball" 1953 Official Picture and Record Book 142078

Cleveland Indians "Play Ball" 1953 Official Picture and Record Book 142078

Regular price $44.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $44.00
Unit price per
Travis Harner Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Hologram 179994

Travis Harner Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Hologram 179994

Regular price $42.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $42.00
Unit price per
Charles Nagy Autographed Rawlings OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA 183200

Charles Nagy Autographed Rawlings OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA 183200

Regular price $39.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $39.00
Unit price per
1964 Cleveland Indians vs. Kansas City Athletics Unscored Program 181364

1964 Cleveland Indians vs. Kansas City Athletics Unscored Program 181364

Regular price $39.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $39.00
Unit price per
Shane Bieber Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 179944

Shane Bieber Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 179944

Regular price $39.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $39.00
Unit price per
Bob Lemon HOF Cleveland Indians Signed/Inscribed 11x14 Photo JSA 164964

Bob Lemon HOF Cleveland Indians Signed/Inscribed 11x14 Photo JSA 164964

Regular price $39.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $39.00
Unit price per
Pat Tabler Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA

Sold out

Pat Tabler Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA

Regular price $39.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $39.00
Unit price per

Sold out
1979 TCMA Baseball Spokane Indians Team Set (39) Cards 189370

1979 TCMA Baseball Spokane Indians Team Set (39) Cards 189370

Regular price $39.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $39.00
Unit price per
Bob Feller/Herb Score Cleveland Indians 9x7 B/W Wire Photo 150317

Bob Feller/Herb Score Cleveland Indians 9x7 B/W Wire Photo 150317

Regular price $39.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $39.00
Unit price per
1983 TCMA Baseball Indianapolis Indians Complete Team Set (32/32) Cards 189382

1983 TCMA Baseball Indianapolis Indians Complete Team Set (32/32) Cards 189382

Regular price $38.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $38.00
Unit price per
Don Schwall Autographed/Inscribed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 179978

Don Schwall Autographed/Inscribed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 179978

Regular price $36.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $36.00
Unit price per
Charles Nagy Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 179943

Charles Nagy Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 179943

Regular price $36.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $36.00
Unit price per
Bob Wickman Cleveland Indians Autographed/Signed OAL Baseball

Bob Wickman Cleveland Indians Autographed/Signed OAL Baseball

Regular price $36.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $36.00
Unit price per
Sean Casey Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA 182627

Sean Casey Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA 182627

Regular price $35.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $35.00
Unit price per
William G. Dailey Indians/Twins Signed Personal Letter from Mobile Motel 151635

William G. Dailey Indians/Twins Signed Personal Letter from Mobile Motel 151635

Regular price $35.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $35.00
Unit price per
Bob Lemon HOF Signed Rawlings OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians No Cert 179954

Sold out

Bob Lemon HOF Signed Rawlings OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians No Cert 179954

Regular price $34.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $34.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Richie Sexson Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians 179953

Richie Sexson Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians 179953

Regular price $34.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $34.00
Unit price per
Earl Averill HOF Autographed 3x5 Index Card Cleveland Indians PSA/DNA 179467

Earl Averill HOF Autographed 3x5 Index Card Cleveland Indians PSA/DNA 179467

Regular price $34.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $34.00
Unit price per
Buddy Bell Cleveland Indians Signed/Autographed Rawlings OAL Baseball JSA 189858

Buddy Bell Cleveland Indians Signed/Autographed Rawlings OAL Baseball JSA 189858

Regular price $34.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $34.00
Unit price per
Mike & Sharon Hargrove Dual-Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 179945

Mike & Sharon Hargrove Dual-Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 179945

Regular price $34.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $34.00
Unit price per
July 06, 2012 Game Used OML Baseball Rays vs. Indians MLB Hologram 181448

July 06, 2012 Game Used OML Baseball Rays vs. Indians MLB Hologram 181448

Regular price $33.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $33.00
Unit price per
July 03, 2012 Game Used OML Baseball Angels vs. Indians MLB Hologram 181447

July 03, 2012 Game Used OML Baseball Angels vs. Indians MLB Hologram 181447

Regular price $33.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $33.00
Unit price per
Earl Averill HOF Cleveland Indians d.1983 Signed/Auto HOF Plaque Postcard 163082

Earl Averill HOF Cleveland Indians d.1983 Signed/Auto HOF Plaque Postcard 163082

Regular price $30.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $30.00
Unit price per
Ken Keltner Cleveland Indians d.1991 Signed/Autographed 3x5 Index Card 162489

Ken Keltner Cleveland Indians d.1991 Signed/Autographed 3x5 Index Card 162489

Regular price $30.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $30.00
Unit price per
Sandy Alomar Jr. Cleveland Indians Signed/Autographed OAL Baseball 163027

Sold out

Sandy Alomar Jr. Cleveland Indians Signed/Autographed OAL Baseball 163027

Regular price $30.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $30.00
Unit price per

Sold out

1
2
3
4
…
8

STAY IN TOUCH

Join our mailing list for new product updates and upcoming sales.

Email

100% Authenticity Always Guaranteed

30-Day Hassle Free Return Policy

Fast & Secure Worldwide Shipping

Friendly Expert Customer Support

Site Links:

Home
About Us
Contact Us

Service Links:

Charity Auction Events
Custom Framing
Store Policies

Explore a Vast Collection of Authentic Sports Memorabilia

Rare and unique sports collectibles at our local store.

Facebook
Instagram
X (Twitter)

Payment methods

© 2025, Best Authentics Powered by Shopify

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.