Skip to content

Facebook
Instagram
X (Twitter)

Welcome to BestAuthentics.com

Trusted Authentic Autographed Memorabilia

20,000 unique items for sale!

Country/region

Canada CAD $
United States USD $

Baseball
Basketball
Football
Hockey
Soccer
Boxing
Golf
Racing & More
Wrestling
Olympics
Entertainment
Political & More
Other
Services

Country/region

Canada CAD $
United States USD $

X (Twitter)
Facebook
Instagram

Search

Baseball
Basketball
Football
Hockey
Soccer
Boxing
Golf
Racing & More
Wrestling
Olympics
Entertainment
Political & More
Other
Services

Search

Item added to your cart

View cart

Collection: MLB Cleveland Indians Memorabilia

Sort by:

265 products

Filter:

Type (0)

Type

Signed (228 products)
Unsigned (7 products)

Products (0)

Products

Balls (129 products)
Bats (1 product)
Index Cards (14 products)
Magazines (3 products)
Photos (89 products)
Postcards (8 products)
Programs (3 products)
Publications (3 products)
Ticket Stubs (1 product)
Trading Cards (4 products)
Yearbooks (1 product)
Misc (2 products)

Condition (0)

Condition

New (220 products)
Very Good (9 products)
Good (2 products)
Used (3 products)
Brand New (1 product)

Price

The highest price is $339.00

$

From

To

Availability (0)

Availability

In stock (225 products)
Out of stock (40 products)

Teams (0)

Teams

MLB Cleveland Indians (131 products)

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

265 products

Type

Signed (228 products)
Unsigned (7 products)

Clear

Products

Balls (129 products)
Bats (1 products)
Index Cards (14 products)
Magazines (3 products)
Photos (89 products)
Postcards (8 products)
Programs (3 products)
Publications (3 products)
Ticket Stubs (1 products)
Trading Cards (4 products)
Yearbooks (1 products)
Misc (2 products)

Clear

Condition

New (220 products)
Very Good (9 products)
Good (2 products)
Used (3 products)
Brand New (1 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $339.00

$

From

$

To

Clear

Availability

In stock (225 products)
Out of stock (40 products)

Clear

Teams

MLB Cleveland Indians (131 products)

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

265 products

Heinie Mueller Phillies d. 1986 Signed/Autographed 3x5 Photo 178660

Heinie Mueller Phillies d. 1986 Signed/Autographed 3x5 Photo 178660

Regular price $29.99

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $29.99
Unit price per
Jack Hannahan Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Hologram 179993

Sold out

Jack Hannahan Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Hologram 179993

Regular price $29.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $29.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Chris Perez Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Hologram 179898

Chris Perez Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Hologram 179898

Regular price $29.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $29.00
Unit price per
Justin Masterson Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Holo 179897

Justin Masterson Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Holo 179897

Regular price $29.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $29.00
Unit price per
Steve Karsay Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA

Steve Karsay Autographed OAL Baseball Cleveland Indians JSA

Regular price $29.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $29.00
Unit price per
Sandy Alomar Indians/Padres Signed/Autographed OML Baseball JSA 141181

Sold out

Sandy Alomar Indians/Padres Signed/Autographed OML Baseball JSA 141181

Regular price $29.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $29.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Mark Lewis Indians Autographed/Signed Baseball Seller 126148 Not Authenticated

Mark Lewis Indians Autographed/Signed Baseball Seller 126148 Not Authenticated

Regular price $29.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $29.00
Unit price per
Juan González Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 179964

Juan González Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 179964

Regular price $26.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $26.00
Unit price per
"Red" Embree Cleveland Indians Autographed/Signed 3x5 Index CArd

"Red" Embree Cleveland Indians Autographed/Signed 3x5 Index CArd

Regular price $26.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $26.00
Unit price per
Bob DiBiasio Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180636

Bob DiBiasio Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180636

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Luis Valbuena Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180632

Sold out

Luis Valbuena Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180632

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Paul Shuey Autographed 1995 AL Champs Baseball Cleveland Indians 180621

Paul Shuey Autographed 1995 AL Champs Baseball Cleveland Indians 180621

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Jeanmar Gómez Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Holo 180616

Jeanmar Gómez Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians MLB Holo 180616

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Tyler Olson Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180552

Tyler Olson Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180552

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Jhonny Peralta Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180551

Jhonny Peralta Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180551

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Carlos Baerga Signed 1995 World Series Logo Baseball Cleveland Indians 180548

Carlos Baerga Signed 1995 World Series Logo Baseball Cleveland Indians 180548

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Russell Branyan Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180547

Russell Branyan Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180547

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Mike Jackson Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180545

Mike Jackson Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180545

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Shelley Duncan Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180543

Shelley Duncan Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180543

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
David Riske Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180541

David Riske Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180541

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Frank Herrman Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180098

Frank Herrman Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180098

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Paul Assenmacher Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180097

Sold out

Paul Assenmacher Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180097

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Brandon Guyer Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180094

Brandon Guyer Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180094

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Eric Wedge/Brian Anderson Dual-Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180090

Eric Wedge/Brian Anderson Dual-Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180090

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Jack Hannahan Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180088

Jack Hannahan Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180088

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Rich Rollins Autographed Cleveland Indians Logo Baseball 180087

Rich Rollins Autographed Cleveland Indians Logo Baseball 180087

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Brandon Guyer Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180085

Brandon Guyer Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180085

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Ben Broussard Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180084

Ben Broussard Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180084

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Ezequiel Carrera Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180083

Ezequiel Carrera Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180083

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Brian Anderson Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180081

Brian Anderson Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180081

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Cody Allen Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180079

Cody Allen Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180079

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Greg Allen Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180078

Greg Allen Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180078

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Dan Otero Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180075

Dan Otero Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180075

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Scott Bailes Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180074

Sold out

Scott Bailes Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180074

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Jason Kipnis Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180071

Sold out

Jason Kipnis Autographed OML Baseball Cleveland Indians 180071

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per

Sold out
Carlos Baerga Autographed 1995 World Series Logo Baseball Indians 180070

Carlos Baerga Autographed 1995 World Series Logo Baseball Indians 180070

Regular price $25.00

Regular price ~~$0.00~~ Sale price $25.00
Unit price per

1
2
3
4
5
…
8

STAY IN TOUCH

Join our mailing list for new product updates and upcoming sales.

Email

100% Authenticity Always Guaranteed

30-Day Hassle Free Return Policy

Fast & Secure Worldwide Shipping

Friendly Expert Customer Support

Site Links:

Home
About Us
Contact Us

Service Links:

Charity Auction Events
Custom Framing
Store Policies

Explore a Vast Collection of Authentic Sports Memorabilia

Rare and unique sports collectibles at our local store.

Facebook
Instagram
X (Twitter)

Payment methods

© 2025, Best Authentics Powered by Shopify

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.